Trigger warning: street/sexual harassment, sexual assault, rape, trauma
It was 21 degrees and sunny when I was out for a walk 2 weeks ago, thermal underwear on underneath my sweatpants, t-shirt, and thick hoodie. I even had my compression gloves on under winter gloves and my compression socks on for extra warmth. Minding my own business, I was playing a game on my phone while listening to No-No Boy through my library’s lending app.
Generally, when I walk anywhere, I walk against traffic. The route I take now is the opposite direction from the one I used to take when someone catcalled me from their car a couple of years ago. Because heaven forbid women, femme/femme presenting people, and non-binary people be allowed to exist in public without being reduced to a sexual object, especially those of us who are Asian.
After reaching the last car entrance for a business I circle around—there is parking all around the building except for one corner—I went for the outdoor stairs (there is a brick wall on the outside so at most you can only see someone’s head) at the corner for a little break while playing the game. After about a minute I stepped into the parking lot, noticing a black sedan that was already past me, backing up. Thinking the driver was going to back into a spot, I didn’t cross as I normally would’ve and walked down further before crossing to get to the apartment complex before ours. As I stepped into the grass between the two parking lots, I heard something behind me and turned around.
The black sedan, window rolled down, and a young man (probably mid-20s) beckoning me over.
Maybe he needs directions.
Maybe he works here and wants to tell me I can’t walk through here.
I pull out an earbud and he says something but I can’t hear him. I stepped closer.
I was wrong on both guesses.
He hit on me.
I can’t remember what he said exactly at first. Something about being his girlfriend.
“No, thanks.”
“Do you have a man?”
“Yes.” I shouldn’t even have to answer this. My initial no should be enough but men still don’t respect us or our bodily autonomy, but they’ll respect the man we’re with. This is why I used to wear a fake engagement ring while clubbing in my 20s. Even in Second Life men have hit on me in IMs with Chaz’s avatar right next to mine. One was so brash that he asked if my marriage was happy, again with Chaz’s avatar RIGHT THERE.
I start to walk away and he asks, “Can we be friends?”
“Sure.”
“Give me your number.”
“No,” I laugh with incredulity. The fucking audacity. I’m 50, in sweats, hood up over my head, clearly listening to something, halfway through a walk, and not even caffeinated for this shit.
“Why?”
“I don’t even know you.”
“That’s how we get to know each other.”
I said goodbye, put my earbud back in, and crossed to the other apartment complex. As I’m walking down the parking lot I notice a black sedan drive by the entrance, coming from my complex.
Is that him? Did he drive out the back and turn around in front of the townhouses?
Which would be an odd thing to do since he could’ve just turned the other way out of the parking lot, but I was on high alert now. Unable to even look at my game until I was at the office. If it was him driving by and he drove into the parking lot I was in, I was in an area I could’ve run into the grass that separates the two complexes, turned a corner, and then ducked into a shortcut to the strip mall we’re behind. Yes, all women have to learn to calculate escape routes, whether someone teaches us or we learn on our own.
We can’t even enjoy a simple walk without having a trauma reaction.
This is why we have #YesAllWomen.
This is why we say it doesn’t matter what we wear or what we look like.
This is why existing in public spaces is exhausting day after day.
This is why we plead with the men we know to speak up and do something.
This is why we get angry when men counter with “not all men.”
It’s enough men that this happens to us often, forcing us to alter what we do and how we do it. It’s enough men that it’s not limited to street harassment. It happens in school, at work, in church (yes it fucking does), in restaurants/bars/clubs, at parties and other social gatherings, in art galleries, in grocery stores…
It happens everywhere, including our own homes amongst family. If I had a nickel for every time a male relative said, “If we weren’t related . . .”
It’s inescapable.
Aging is not a deterrence from being approached in public. It’s one thing to strike up a conversation while waiting in a long line, it’s quite another thing to stop me in the middle of Kroger for no reason other than the man thinks he can, should, and I owe him my time and attention. Or to attempt to make chiding commentary on my graphic t-shirt because he thinks I need a lecture and he’s the one to give it, being the exact reason I wore my “I HATE PEOPLE” shirt—he had a kid with him and was blocked by other carts while I just had a basket and was able to dart away without him following me. But I was still hyperalert until I was in my car.
I should be able to take a walk in my neighborhood and not have to worry about walking against traffic, escape routes, men stopping me just to hit on me, or men catcalling, disrupting a peaceful part of my day. Every girl, woman, femme/femme presenting person, and non-binary person should be able to. I should be able to have interactions with men that don’t lead to me questioning if he fetishizes Asian women. I should be able to go into a grocery store and only be interrupted by employees making sure I’m finding what I need. I should be able to log into Second Life without men not even in local chat distance, IM’ing me to hit on me and then turning verbally abusive when I turn them down, accusing me of being a tease. Even in Second Life men seem to think we create our avatars to please them and not our own self. It’s inconceivable to these men that we dress, do our hair, and our makeup to feel good about ourselves. A low-cut, skin-tight dress {or insert your favorite here} can remind us of our power, strength, and badassery.
When I went to clubs in college, it was to dance. Never to attract other men. But there are expectations for club attire. It’s a Catch-22 in which we have to dress a certain way if we want to gain entry and then men get angry because we’re being “provocative” or “a tease.” No, they saw me as a sexual object and when I didn’t respond as they expected, they twisted their issue into my fault. We’ve seen it play out over and over again in the media when allegations are made public: a woman is just existing and when she doesn’t consent the men twist their expectations into being her fault. Even judges and lawyers who are men will make the defendant’s expectation the victim’s fault. Remember the judge who asked the victim if she tried keeping her legs closed? How about the lawyer in Ireland who used the 17-year-old victim’s underwear as a sign of consent and the rapist was acquitted?
As I processed what happened in the parking lot internally and shared with a few close friends, memories of other incidents resurfaced. The aforementioned incident in Second Life in which the man asked if my marriage was happy. The subordinate at work who repeatedly used intimidation tactics to get what he wanted (threatening to report me to my direct supervisor, using our residents like they were his wingmen, barring the one and only exit to our staff office leaving me with no escape), and even though I gave detailed written reports to my supervisor on these incidents, neither he nor HR asked about or saw to my safety in the workplace.
No matter what we do, it never deters nor keeps us completely safe.
Here are the ways I’ve had to protect myself/change what I do (not remotely comprehensive):
- Wear headphones/earbuds to listen to music while walking and taking public transportation
- Check all the exits inside public spaces and plan escape routes
- Sit in public spaces where men can’t sneak up behind me
- Plan escape routes outdoors
- Walk against traffic even if there is no sidewalk
- Carried pepper spray
- Walked with my keys between my fingers
- Walked with my umbrella in hand, ready to use as a weapon
- Attempt to be late to the two classes I had with my stalker (I usually wasn’t no matter how hard I tried, but as long as I got there after him so he couldn’t sit near me I was good)
- Screened phone calls to avoid talking to my stalker
- Wore fake engagement ring when clubbing
- Until recently, I never stated my age online
- No social media check-ins, geotagging, or posting about a place while I’m still there
- Given fake numbers to men who refused to leave me alone
- Purposefully look like a slob (didn’t work)
- Made sure I was listed in the White Pages as Last Name, First Initial with my phone number, no address even after I married Chaz
- Cut off all contact with my emotionally abusive ex even though it meant cutting off contact with mutual friends
If you’re a man reading this, women you know have done some or all of these as well as some I didn’t list while you don’t have to think twice about protecting yourselves in these ways while you’re in public. The girls you know are being taught these things whether you are aware of them or not.
If you read Tainted Love, you know Ari did some of these to protect herself and they were never foolproof. While several of my points in TL were focused on issues AsAm women face with other AsAms and with non-AsAms, I made sure to include incidents that affect girls, women, femmes, and femme presenting people broadly in a way to show how even if these things occur on different days, they become cumulative stressors leading to trauma. The first episode of Peacemaker has a perfect scene with this playing out [the following might be spoilery so skip to the next paragraph if you haven’t seen the first episode and intend to see it soon] of Harcourt in a bar minding her own business, just drinking a beer and keeping to herself. Guy 1 comes up to her, runs a finger down her arm, and asks if he can ask a question. She insults him since he touched her and got in her personal space. Guy 2, someone she knows, comes in and starts chatting her up the way we’ve had countless “friends” start off before they hit on us. Guy 3, friend of Guy 1, starts yelling at her from across the bar, storms over, probably counting on verbally and physically intimidating her. Once that confrontation ends, she returns to her beer where Guy 2 continues to go on about his needs and that it could be fun for both of them. He doesn’t really care about what she wants or needs, both to have men stop hitting on her and just leave her alone to drink her beer. He doesn’t really care if it’s “fun” for her. He just wanted sex and he was hoping she’d agree.
We all know when men proclaim that discrimination against a group of marginalized people is for the “safety of women” that it’s complete bullshit. If they really wanted to keep us safe, they wouldn’t be creating stories out of whole cloth to oppress marginalized people. They would be going after police departments that suppress evidence or even ignore reports altogether while treating the victim as if she is a liar seeking attention (Netflix’s “Unbelievable” is based on the true events of Marie Adler’s report not being taken seriously and how police charged her with filing a false report). They would be going after judges who have a history of giving haole abusers lenient sentences while giving Black and Brown men the harshest sentences. They would be ensuring funding for the testing of rape kits in every single community. They would be pushing for reform in how victims are treated by the system when they report: a big reason we don’t report is the fear of being re-victimized by police, prosecutors, defense attorneys, journalists, and the general public—all it takes is one “Why didn’t you [insert victim blaming here]?” to shut us down for our own safety. They would formalize national standards for higher education in regards to reporting and investigations that should include police involvement—some use internal councils only, ensuring no legal charges are filed against the abuser. There are so many more things that they could do in the name of our “safety” that would really help but are unwilling to do because it means getting caught in the net themselves.
To the men reading this, do more to help dismantle the systems that cover for sexual harassers/abusers and challenge the men around you when they’re crossing the line. That’s going to mean that you need to learn the subtlest of offenses that you might not think of as harassment or abuse; kind of like racial microaggressions and how those of us on the receiving end know them when we hear them but those who don’t experience them don’t know them when they hear them or say them themselves. I’ve had men friends tell me the men they’re around don’t do these things but I’m not so sure that it’s not that they don’t do them, but that maybe they don’t recognize it when it’s not overt. This isn’t just a women’s issue. It affects all of us in one way or another.